Sean Carroll (What to think about machines that think)Sean Carroll

Sean Carroll argues that the boundary between natural and artificial intelligence is blurring. He references 18th-century French philosopher Julien de La Mettrie, who asserted that humans are essentially thinking machines. Carroll suggests that modern physics and neuroscience support this view. He notes that artificial intelligence development has been challenging because it requires an integration of … Read more

Marcelo Gleiser (What to think about machines that think)

Marcelo Gleiser argues that humans have already become transhuman, deeply integrated with technology in ways that extend our physical and mental capabilities. He challenges the traditional notion that artificial intelligence will exist separately and potentially in opposition to humans. Instead, Gleiser envisions a future where AI serves as an extension of human intelligence, amplifying our … Read more

Pamela McCorduck (What to think about machines that think)

Pamela McCorduck reflects on the evolving public opinion on AI, acknowledging its significance as a transformative scientific, technological, and social event. She posits that AI could serve as a complementary intelligence to humans, citing the example of chess where human-machine teams outperform either alone. McCorduck mentions the AI100 project at Stanford University, funded for a … Read more

Tomaso Poggio (What to think about machines that think)

Tomaso Poggio advocates for interdisciplinary research in understanding intelligence, integrating cognitive science, neuroscience, and computer science. He argues that the quest to understand and replicate intelligence in machines is not only beneficial but essential for societal advancement. Poggio emphasizes that intelligence is not a singular entity but a set of solutions to various problems, making … Read more

Tomaso Poggio (What to think about machines that think)

Tomaso Poggio advocates for interdisciplinary research in understanding intelligence, integrating cognitive science, neuroscience, and computer science. He argues that the quest to understand and replicate intelligence in machines is not only beneficial but essential for societal advancement. Poggio emphasizes that intelligence is not a singular entity but a set of solutions to various problems, making … Read more

Max Tegmark (What to think about machines that think)

Max Tegmark emphasizes the importance of proactive research and preparation for the societal impact of AI. He argues that the focus should shift from debating the possibilities to taking concrete actions. Tegmark lists common misconceptions that distract from the real issues, such as scaremongering and the belief that machines can’t have goals. He stresses that … Read more

Timo Hannay (What to think about machines that think)

Timo Hannay discusses the rapid advancement of machine intelligence, noting its increasing capabilities in data processing and decision-making. While acknowledging concerns about machines surpassing human intelligence and control, Hannay argues that current AI is still narrow and specialized compared to human versatility. He believes humans and machines will continue to complement each other in complex … Read more

David Christian (What to think about machines that think)

David Christian explores the concept of thinking in the context of the universe’s history. He argues that thinking is an emergent property of increasingly complex networks, from stars to living organisms. Living organisms, unlike inanimate objects, must adapt to unstable environments, leading to homeostasis and decision-making abilities. Neurons in brains expand these abilities exponentially. Humans … Read more

John C. Mather (What to think about machines that think)

John C. Mather discusses the inevitable rise of powerful artificial intelligence, driven by competition and vast investments in various sectors like business, medicine, and warfare. He warns that the rapid evolution of AI could lead to societal upheaval, questioning who will control these entities and the ethical implications of their widespread use. Mather is intrigued … Read more

Kevin P. Hand (What to think about machines that think)

Kevin P. Hand explores the Fermi Paradox in the context of superintelligent machines, questioning whether such entities would be motivated to explore the universe. He argues that the primary human reasons for exploration—freedom, curiosity, and resource acquisition—may not apply to superintelligent beings. Resource needs could be met within a single star system, and curiosity could … Read more