Unearned Wisdom reader route

Psychology Ideas Under Pressure

A critical companion for readers who want more than a summary of an influential psychology book, theory, or claim.

What did this psychology idea actually claim, where does it help, and where does it overreach?

Critical notes on psychology

Get careful notes on influential psychology ideas: what they illuminate, what they omit, and the questions that remain.

Browse the relevant archive

Use Read Psychology Critically

Go further with The 30 Greatest Psychology Books

A reader’s companion to 30 influential psychology books, examining what they argued and where they go wrong.

See whether The 30 Greatest Psychology Books is for you

Join on Substack

  1. Choose one theory or book that is often cited more than it is examined.
  2. Use the annotation framework to distinguish its strongest insight from its broadest claim.
  3. Continue with a critical companion to influential psychology books rather than a list of conclusions to inherit.